Akerly Law · PACA Resources
When a Produce Recall Hits the Supply Chain: PACA Questions Sellers Should Ask
September 3, 2026
An FDA investigation into a multistate Salmonella Javiana outbreak linked to fresh jalapeños from Sinaloa, Mexico illustrates how quickly a produce recall can spread through the supply chain.
In its August 21, 2026 update, FDA reported that its investigation remained ongoing and that downstream recalls were being conducted for jalapeños distributed by a produce company and products containing them. FDA advised consumers not to eat the recalled products and affected businesses not to sell, serve, or use them.1
For produce businesses, the immediate priority is protecting consumers and complying with recall guidance. But commercial disputes can follow quickly: Who bears the loss? Can the buyer reject the shipment or withhold payment? Were the goods already accepted? Do PACA rights and deadlines also come into play? These commercial questions can arise before the business has completed its operational recall response, and they require a separate review of the transaction.
Executive Summary
A produce recall can create payment, documentation, and PACA questions before the operational response is complete. This article outlines how sellers can separate the recall response from the payment analysis, preserve key records, review payment terms and invoice language, and flag potential PACA trust or deadline issues early. Organized records can help the business and its counsel evaluate the transaction, identify relevant deadlines, and determine what options may be available based on the facts.
A Recall Does Not Automatically Decide the Payment Issue
A food safety recall and a payment dispute are related, but they are not the same issue.
A recall does not, by itself, determine whether a buyer may reject the shipment, withhold the entire purchase price, or recover damages. Those questions can depend on the contract, the timing and manner of acceptance or rejection, the product’s condition, the recall’s scope, and the evidence preserved by the parties.
USDA guidance distinguishes between acceptance, rightful rejection, wrongful rejection, and the remedies available after accepted goods are found to be nonconforming. That distinction can matter when a buyer refuses to pay, claims damages, requests credits, or says the product was rejected, destroyed, or disposed of.2
For sellers, the practical point is simple: do not assume the recall alone resolves the payment issue. Review the documents, preserve the evidence, and evaluate the transaction before more time passes.
Start With the Product and the Paper Trail
When a recall affects a produce transaction, the first step is factual. The business should identify what product was involved, where it came from, where it went, and which records support each step.
Key questions include:
- What commodity was sold?
- Who supplied it?
- Who received it?
- When was the product shipped and delivered, and was it accepted, rejected, held, destroyed, returned, or resold?
- Which lot codes, traceability records, recall notices, and shipment records apply?
- What invoices, bills of lading, purchase orders, accountings, inspection records, photographs, or communications exist?
- Are there temperature records, credit requests, destruction records, or disposition records?
- Has the buyer paid any portion of the invoice?
USDA identifies documents such as invoices, contracts, bills of lading, broker’s memoranda of sale, manifests, and accountings as examples of records that can be relevant in PACA-related claims.3 The more complete the paper trail is, the easier it is to evaluate both the recall issue and the payment issue.
Sellers should also be careful before product is destroyed, discarded, or otherwise disposed of. If destruction or disposition is necessary, the business should document what happened and consider whether inspection, photographs, written confirmation, or other evidence should be preserved first.
Separate the Recall Response From the Payment Analysis
The recall response focuses on tracing product, notifying customers, holding affected inventory, removing product from the market, and following public health guidance.
The payment analysis is different. It looks at whether the buyer accepted or rejected the product, whether payment was withheld, whether contract terms apply, whether credits or damages are disputed, whether PACA trust rights were preserved, and whether the seller has recovery options.
These issues can overlap and may proceed at the same time, but each requires its own analysis. A buyer’s refusal to pay, a seller’s demand for payment, or a disagreement over rejected product can turn on the facts, documents, timing, and preserved evidence.
Review PACA Early
PACA is a federal law governing fair trading practices in the fresh and frozen fruits and vegetables industry. Among other things, it addresses payment obligations and provides a framework for resolving disputes between buyers and sellers.4
If a payment issue develops after a recall, PACA rights and deadlines may also come into play. The PACA trust provision can protect unpaid sellers in qualifying transactions, but those rights depend on specific requirements.5
PACA provides two principal methods of preserving trust rights. A PACA licensee may provide notice through the exact statutory language on its ordinary and usual invoices or billing statements. Alternatively, a seller may provide a separate written notice of intent to preserve trust benefits. Under the separate-notice method, notice generally must be provided within 30 days after payment became due or after the seller received notice that a timely submitted payment was dishonored.6
Other important timing and payment-term requirements include:
- Payment terms different from PACA’s prompt-payment rules generally must be agreed to in writing before the transaction.
- When the parties use payment terms different from PACA’s prompt-payment rules, those terms must be disclosed on invoices, accountings, and other documents relating to the transaction.
- To qualify for PACA trust protection, payment terms generally cannot exceed 30 days from receipt and acceptance of the product.
- A PACA reparation complaint generally must be filed within nine months after payment was due or contractual performance was required.
- The nine-month reparation deadline does not extend the shorter deadlines that may apply to preserving PACA trust rights.
The applicable requirements and deadlines depend on the transaction, documents, payment terms, preservation method, and other facts.
Watch for Accounts Receivable Risk
A recall can create uncertainty inside an accounts receivable process. A buyer may delay payment while reviewing its own exposure. A customer may request credits. A distributor may receive mixed information from multiple parties. A seller may assume the issue is being handled operationally while payment deadlines continue to matter.
Produce businesses should have a process for flagging invoices connected to recalled or disputed product.
That process should include:
- Identifying all affected invoices
- Confirming payment due dates
- Reviewing whether any payment was dishonored
- Preserving buyer communications
- Confirming payment terms
- Confirming which trust-preservation method was used and whether its requirements were satisfied
- Escalating the issue if payment is delayed or disputed
The goal is to keep a payment issue from being treated as routine when PACA deadlines, documentation, or trust preservation questions are involved.
First 24 to 48 Hours After a Recall-Related Payment Dispute
When a recall leads to withheld payment, rejected product, or disputed invoices, sellers should move quickly to organize the facts.
Important early steps include:
- Identify the affected shipments, invoices, customers, and lot codes.
- Preserve recall notices, traceability records, shipment records, invoices, purchase orders, and bills of lading.
- Save buyer communications, credit requests, payment promises, rejection notices, and dispute correspondence.
- Confirm whether the product was accepted, rejected, held, destroyed, returned, or resold.
- Preserve photographs, inspection records, temperature records, and disposition or destruction records.
- Confirm payment due dates and any written payment terms.
- Determine whether PACA trust rights were preserved through the required invoice language or a separate written notice of intent to preserve trust benefits.
- Confirm whether any payment was dishonored.
- Avoid destroying product or evidence without documenting what happened and considering inspection needs.
- Contact counsel if payment is being withheld or deadlines may be approaching.
These steps do not resolve every legal issue, but they support a faster and more informed evaluation of the seller’s position.
When to Contact PACA Counsel
Consider contacting PACA counsel promptly if:
- A buyer is withholding payment for recalled product.
- The buyer claims to have rejected, destroyed, or disposed of the shipment.
- The parties disagree about credits, damages, or responsibility for downstream losses.
- Payment terms or PACA trust notices may be defective.
- A check or electronic payment has been dishonored.
- The buyer appears financially distressed.
- A deadline for preserving trust rights or filing a PACA reparation complaint may be approaching.
- The dispute involves multiple invoices, a meaningful balance, or a repeat customer relationship.
Early review can help a seller understand whether PACA applies, what documents matter, what deadlines may be involved, and what recovery options may be available.
The Bottom Line
A produce recall can move fast. Product may be pulled from the market, customers may demand answers, and payment disputes may develop before the business has finished sorting through the facts.
For produce sellers, distributors, and suppliers, the best time to organize records and review PACA issues is early in the process. When payment is delayed, disputed, or tied to recalled product, the details can matter.
If a recall has resulted in withheld payment, disputed invoices, rejected product, or uncertainty about PACA trust rights, early review can be critical. Akerly Law helps produce sellers evaluate contracts, preserve PACA rights, and pursue payment before important deadlines expire.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Recall-related disputes, PACA rights, and applicable deadlines depend on the specific transaction and circumstances.
[1] U.S. Food and Drug Administration, “Outbreak Investigation of Salmonella: Jalapeño (August 2026),” August 21, 2026 update, discussing the agency’s ongoing investigation of a multistate Salmonella Javiana outbreak linked to fresh jalapeños from Sinaloa, Mexico, including downstream recalls of jalapeños and products containing recalled jalapeños.
[2] U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service, “Top 10 Contracting Issues,” discussing acceptance, rightful rejection, wrongful rejection, and remedies after accepted goods are found to be nonconforming.
[3] U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service, “Common Questions & Answers,” discussing documentary evidence for PACA-related claims.
[4] U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service, “Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA)”; see also 7 U.S.C. § 499a et seq.
[5] See 7 U.S.C. § 499e(c); 7 C.F.R. § 46.46; U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service, “PACA Trust.”
[6] See 7 U.S.C. § 499e(c)(3)–(4); 7 C.F.R. § 46.46(e)–(f); U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service, “PACA Trust” and “Common Questions & Answers.”
Have a PACA question?
If you are dealing with an unpaid produce invoice, a PACA trust claim, or need to protect your rights under the PACA, our team can help.