In 2017, Mr. Akerly presented a paper entitled How To Bust A Trust to the North Texas Estate Planning Council and the Rio Grande Valley Estate Planning Counsel
Does a PACA Trust Give Rise to an Actionable Fiduciary Capacity Claim Under § 523(A)(4)?
Section 523(a)(4) of the Bankruptcy Code exempts from discharge a debt “for fraud or defalcation while acting in a fiduciary capacity.” While the Code does not specifically define the term “fiduciary capacity” courts have coalesced around an interpretation that acting in a fiduciary capacity means something more than merely having a fiduciary duty. Produce dealers under the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (“PACA”), 7 U.S.C §§ 499e(c), have a fiduciary duty to protect produce suppliers. Congress adopted PACA in 1930 to protect farmers and suppliers by imposing a floating trust on the inventory and proceeds of a purchaser. Court’s have expanded the company trust obligation to include persons who are owners of a business and in a position to affect and manage the business’ financial operations.
In Coosemans Miami Inc. v. Arthur (In re Arthur), No. 17-1378 (Bankr. S.D. Fla. Aug, 6, 2018), the debtor was the owner and operator of a fresh produce wholesaler that was subject to PACA. Prior to bankruptcy, the debtor was sued under PACA by produce suppliers; this suit ended with the debtor, a person responsible for the business and financial affairs of the company, having joint and several liability for almost $300,000 in produce debt. When the debtor/officer declared bankruptcy the produce suppliers sued claiming that under Section 523(a)(4) the debt was non-dischargeable.
The Court considered the question of whether the “PACA trust give[s] rise to an actionable fiduciary capacity under § 523(a)(4)?” The decision to allow discharge turned on the interpretation that only a technical trust falls under Section 523(a)(4) and, until the Court imposes additional duties no technical trust exists, as to individuals, under PACA. In support, the Court cited two points. First, since PACA dealers can comingle trust assets with other assets, a PACA trust is not a technical trust until additional restrictions are imposed by the court. Second, the right to use trust assets for non-trust purposes is fatal to finding a technical trust exists. See Texas Lottery Commission v. Tran (In re Tran), 151 F.3d 339, 343-44 (5th Cir. 1988).
Judge Mark does cite cases which held that segregation of trust funds is not required to be a technical trust, but he found these unpersuasive. Additionally, the Court notes that most courts have held that a PACA trust is a technical, albeit statutory, trust. While this Court has found these decisions unpersuasive it does note the split amongst courts and certified the question to the Circuit Court for clarity.
Share:
More Posts

When a Produce Buyer Files for Bankruptcy: What Happens to PACA Trust Claims?
Learn how PACA trust claims are treated when a produce buyer files for bankruptcy, including covered trust assets, preserving trust rights, and asserting a claim.

Filing or Responding to a PACA Reparation Complaint: What Produce Businesses Should Know
Learn how to file or respond to a PACA reparation complaint, including USDA filing and response deadlines, supporting records, and what happens after a reparation order.

When a PACA License Is at Risk: What “Responsibly Connected” Can Mean for Owners and Officers
Learn what “responsibly connected” means under PACA and how sanctions can affect owners and officers through employment, licensing, and surety bond requirements.

PACA Prompt Payment Requirements: What Buyers Should Know About Late Payments and USDA Enforcement
Learn about PACA prompt-payment deadlines, documenting negotiated terms, handling disputed balances, and what recent USDA enforcement means for produce buyers.